This is the Cigarette Card location for the President Alfred Macalister card. It is on the window sill to your right when you first walk into the Crawdad Willies shack.

President Alfred Macalister is card 12 in the Prominent Americans set. The reward for completing this set is Three Eagle Feathers and $50.

In addition to the individual set rewards, the reward for completing your first Cigarette Card set is the Vintage Civil War Handcuffs. The handcuffs are required to craft the Alligator Tooth Talisman; A unique item that reduces Dead Eye core drain by 10%.